🔗 Share this article

Across several weeks, coercive messages persisted. At first, reportedly from an ex-law enforcement official and an ex-military commander, and then from the authorities. In the end, one resident claims he was ordered to law enforcement headquarters and instructed bluntly: remain silent or experience severe repercussions.

This third-generation resident is one of many opposing a expensive project where one of India's largest slums – an iconic Mumbai neighborhood – is scheduled to be razed and modernized by a large business group.

"The distinctive community of Dharavi is exceptional in the world," explains the protester. "Yet the plan aims to destroy our community and stop us speaking out."

Contrasting Realities

The cramped lanes of the slum sit in stark contrast to the soaring skyscrapers and elite residences that dominate the neighborhood. Residences are constructed informally and frequently missing basic amenities, unregulated industries produce dangerous fumes and the air is filled with the suffocating smell of uncovered waste channels.

For certain residents, the prospect of the slum's redevelopment into a glistening neighborhood of premium apartments, well-maintained green spaces, shiny shopping centers and homes with multiple bathrooms is an aspirational dream come true.

"We don't have sufficient health services, roads or drainage and there are no spaces for children to play," says A Selvin Nadar, 56, who migrated from Tamil Nadu in that period. "The single option is to clear the area and construct proper housing."

Local Protest

Yet certain residents, including this protester, are opposing the project.

Everyone acknowledges that this community, historically ignored as informal housing, is desperately requiring economic input and modernization. But they fear that this initiative – absent of resident participation – is one that will turn a piece of prime Mumbai real estate into a playground for the rich, evicting the disadvantaged, working-class residents who have resided there since the nineteenth century.

It was these marginalized, displaced people who developed the uninhabited area into an extensively researched phenomenon of self-reliance and commercial output, whose production is estimated at between a significant amount and $2m per year, making it among the globe's biggest unregulated sectors.

Resettlement Issues

Of the roughly one million residents living in the packed 2.2 square kilometer zone, less than 50% will be qualified for replacement housing in the project, which is projected to take an extended timeframe to accomplish. Others will be moved to wastelands and coastal regions on the remote edges of Mumbai, potentially break up a long-established neighborhood. Some will be denied homes at all.

People eligible to remain in the area will be allocated flats in multi-story structures, a major break from the organic, shared lifestyle of dwelling and laboring that has maintained Dharavi for many years.

Commercial activities from clothing production to clay work and material recovery are expected to decrease in quantity and be relocated to a specific "business area" far from residential areas.

Survival Challenge

In the case of this protester, a workshop owner and multi-generational of his family to call home the slum, the redevelopment presents an existential threat. His informal, multi-level workshop creates garments – formal jackets, premium outerwear, studded bomber jackets – distributed in premium stores in south Mumbai and internationally.

His family dwells in the spaces below and laborers and tailors – migrants from other states – also sleep on-site, enabling him to sustain operations. Beyond this community, accommodation prices are typically significantly costlier for basic accommodation.

Threats and Warning

At the government offices close by, an illustrated mock-up of the transformation initiative depicts a contrasting perspective. Well-groomed people mill about on cycles and electric vehicles, buying western-style baguettes and croissants and enlisting beverages on an outdoor area near Dharavi Cafe and dessert parlor. This depicts a world away from the inexpensive idli sambar first meal and low-cost tea that supports local residents.

"This is not progress for our community," explains Shaikh. "It's an enormous land development that will render it impossible for residents to remain."

Additionally, there exists concern of the corporate group. Headed by a powerful tycoon – a leading figure and a supporter of the national leader – the conglomerate has encountered allegations of preferential treatment and financial impropriety, which it disputes.

While the state government labels it a partnership, the developer contributed a significant amount for its majority share. Legal proceedings stating that the project was questionably assigned to the developer is under review in the top court.

Sustained Harassment

Since they began to vocally oppose the redevelopment, protesters and community members claim they have been subjected to ongoing efforts of pressure and threats – including messages, explicit warnings and implications that opposing the development was tantamount to anti-national sentiment – by individuals they assert work for the developer.

Included in these accused of issuing the threats is {a retired police officer|a former law enforcement official|an ex-c